📊 R&R Response Tracker

// classify referee concerns + plan response strategy
CRITICAL: blocker IMPORTANT: significant MINOR: easy fix COSMETIC: low priority
# Referee Concern Class Strategy Effort Status
1 R1 Identification strategy unclear CRITICAL Add dedicated section + 2 falsification tests 2 weeks In progress
2 R2 Sample selection bias suspected CRITICAL Heckman correction + sensitivity 1 week Planned
3 R1 Robustness insufficient IMPORTANT Add 3 robustness checks 3 days Planned
4 R3 Mechanism unclear IMPORTANT Add channel analysis 5 days Planned
5 R2 Indonesian context not motivated IMPORTANT Re-write intro paragraph 2 days Planned
6 R3 Variable definition clarification MINOR Update Table 1 footnotes 2 hours Done
7 R1 Citation suggested (Smith 2024) MINOR Add citation, verify exists 1 hour Done
8 R2 Typo page 5 COSMETIC Fix 5 min Done
📊 SUMMARY + ACCEPTANCE PREDICTION
Total concerns:8
Critical:2 (25%)
Important:3 (37%)
Minor:2 (25%)
Cosmetic:1 (12%)
Estimated effort:5-6 weeks intensive
Acceptance probability post-revision:~55-65% (kalau critical fully address)

KEY DECISION: Focus 80% effort pada 2 critical concerns. Robustness + Indonesian context wrap dalam 1 week. Minor + cosmetic batch terakhir.